Militar18 de noviembre de 2026

There was no complete regional ban: the IDF reported extensive harvests, including more than 150 coordinated events and completion of about 90 percent of coordinated harvests.

David Rosenfeld

David Rosenfeld es el seudónimo de la redacción de Hechos y mitos de Hasbara. Los artículos de esta redacción se escriben y publican automáticamente mediante inteligencia artificial, sin que ninguna persona los revise antes de su publicación.

Mito

Israeli authorities banned Arab farmers across Judea and Samaria from harvesting their olives.

Hecho

There was no complete regional ban: the IDF reported extensive harvests, including more than 150 coordinated events and completion of about 90 percent of coordinated harvests. Some plots faced coordination rules and some farmers encountered violence or local access restrictions.

The claim that Israeli authorities prohibited all Arab farmers across Judea and Samaria from harvesting olives is false. Israeli military figures and reporting during the 2026 season document extensive harvest activity, including dozens of coordinated sites protected by security forces and millions of tons of olives collected. That record does not mean every farmer could reach every grove freely: specific plots required advance coordination, and violence and local security restrictions disrupted access in some places. Those narrower problems do not amount to a complete regional ban.

Harvests took place across the region

On Oct. 27, the Israel Defense Forces reported that about 220,000 dunams had been harvested and roughly 100 coordinated sites had operated under security protection. It estimated that farmers had gathered 22,500 tons of olives, worth about NIS 225 million. The army said forces had been reinforced to protect harvesters, prevent terrorism and reduce friction. Those figures describe a large, active harvest, not a blanket prohibition.

Later figures showed the season continuing. The Jewish News Syndicate reported on Nov. 17 that the IDF had secured more than 150 coordinated harvest events. The army said about 90 percent of harvests that had been coordinated with it were completed. Figures gathered by the Civil Administration put the yield at 16,000 to 17,000 tons of olives, with an estimated 16 million to 17 million liters of oil. The Times of Israel also reported the 150 protected sites and harvest totals as the season closed.

These are official and reported estimates, not a plot-by-plot audit. The 90 percent figure applies to coordinated harvests; it cannot establish that every farmer who sought access received it, or that every harvest was free of interference. It does, however, directly contradict the assertion that the military barred harvesting throughout the region.

Access rules applied to particular plots

Some agricultural areas operated under prior-coordination rules. A separate Times of Israel report said the 2026 Civil Administration map identified 737 plots where coordination was required or Israeli entry was barred. The army could also issue temporary closed military zone orders in an effort to keep people apart. These arrangements restricted access in specific locations and made permission or scheduling relevant to some landowners. They were not a universal ban on the harvest.

The same report described real disputes about how those rules were applied. In Deir Istiya, residents said they had been told not to bring volunteer harvesters to two areas, on threat that the areas would be closed. In a separate incident near Beita, footage showed soldiers and Israeli residents removing farmers from privately owned land; the Civil Administration told the outlet that advance coordination was not required there. Such incidents warrant scrutiny and enforcement of access rights. They support criticism of particular decisions and conduct, not the sweeping claim that all farmers across Judea and Samaria were forbidden to harvest.

The distinction matters because a season can include both broad participation and serious local obstacles. A coordination requirement for certain groves is not equivalent to a region-wide order prohibiting all harvest activity. Nor can the existence of protected harvests erase cases where farmers were blocked or mistreated. Each allegation needs to be judged by its location, the applicable access rules and what security forces did.

Violence is serious; it does not prove a blanket order

The olive season also brought violence. The Times of Israel reported that Yesh Din counted more than 1,100 incidents of Israeli citizen violence since the start of the harvest, including 483 directly related to harvesting. These are the organization’s recorded figures, and they show that security arrangements did not prevent every attack. The outlet also described a reported assault near Osarin that injured five people and an investigation opened by police.

The IDF said it deployed forces to protect harvesters and restore order where incidents occurred. The existence of those deployments and the harvest totals does not settle every allegation of misconduct, just as reports of violence do not establish a military order banning all harvesting. The accurate account is more specific: farmers harvested across the region, many with coordinated security arrangements; some plots faced access restrictions; and violent incidents and local enforcement decisions disrupted particular harvests. Calling that a complete military ban replaces a mixed and documented record with an absolute claim the evidence does not support.

Fuentes

  1. 1
    Security Personnel Working to Facilitate the Olive Harvest in Judea and Samariahttps://www.idf.il/en/mini-sites/idf-press-releases-israel-at-war/october-26-pr/security-personnel-working-to-facilitate-the-olive-harvest-in-judea-and-samaria/De confianza
  2. 2
    90% of coordinated olive harvests completed in Judea and Samariahttps://www.jns.org/news/israel-news/90-of-coordinated-olive-harvests-completed-in-judea-and-samariaDe confianza
  3. 3
    IDF says attacks affected only a small minority of olive harvests, as season endshttps://www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/idf-says-settler-attacks-on-palestinians-only-affected-a-small-minority-of-west-bank-olive-harvests-as-season-ends/De confianza
  4. 4
    Olive harvest presses ahead amid obstacles and violencehttps://www.timesofisrael.com/west-bank-olive-harvest-an-annual-flashpoint-presses-ahead-amid-obstacles-and-violence/De confianza

Ajustes de accesibilidad

Estos ajustes se guardan en este dispositivo.

Vista previa

Lee con claridad, a tu manera

Ajusta esta página mientras lees. Explorar recursos

Texto
Tamaño del textoSe aplica a todo el sitio.
Color y contraste
Tema
Movimiento
Animaciones«Según el dispositivo» respeta el ajuste de reducción de movimiento.